I find it amusing when you see calculators designed to justify one parent in a family staying at home. Not because that’s not a worthy goal if it suits you, but because they are about how you can live on one income. And I live on one income. But that’s because I’m single.
Now, I’m assuming that some of the challenges of supporting multiple people on one income are significantly greater than supporting a single person on one income. It seems reasonable that there will be higher food bills, somewhat higher utility bills, and possibly (although not necessarily) higher housing costs.
On the other hand, there are perceived advantages to having a stay at home adult in the household, that don’t apply to single people. From three hierarchies
…a single-income family can respond to a loss of the breadwinner’s income (for whatever reason: death, injury, laid-off, fired, etc.) by sending the other parent into the paid labor force. Dual-income families don’t have that option…
Single income single person families don’t have this option either. Nor do they have someone to pick up the slack in the housework department, or to run errands in working hours.
Although there might be smaller bills, it’s harder to be more creatively frugal when you don’t have all that much time - not really even as much as a dual income household, where there are at least two busy people to do the work instead of one. There is also often an unwritten assumption that because you are single, you have plenty of time to help people out. Hmmm, not so much.
Some of the difficulties are shared. The Two Income Trap argues that middle class two income families have driven up housing prices and made single income living much more difficult as you have to pay for a lot of house on your budget. That’s as true for single person families as it is for multiple person families.
To a greater extent than in a larger family, single income, single adult living isn’t really a choice. I can’t just decide to be in a dual income household. It’s a pity that it is so expensive - most people live a single life at some point, and more than half of everyone finishes up their days being a single person household.
Don’t get me wrong, I do enjoy my single life, it has many advantages, but it is more expensive than being in a dual income household.
What you describe is the rationale behind the “marriage (tax) penalty” here in the U.S. Married couples pay more in taxes than a single person who makes the same amount would. I nearly had a heart attack the first year we were married because I’d always gotten a refund, and yet now we owed $2000!
I’m not a fan of that - we have taxation on individuals, not on households over here. It doesn’t matter whether you are married or single, you are taxed on your own income.
I had been supporting myself for quite some time before getting married last year. And I agree with you whole-heartedly. Two incomes are better than one. Many of the costs stay the same (heat, phone, mortgage)yet you have twice the money.
Lisa
I just got married this year as well, and completely agree. Being a single homeowner working full time is hard work!
My husband and I sold my house when we got married and I moved into his. Now, I never have to find time to shovel the driveway (snow) and he never has to go grocery shopping! I don’t have to do dishes and he doesn’t have to do laundry. It really is a time saver and gives both of us more free time to relax together!
As an added bonus, 100% of my income goes into savings (we combine all of our finances)!
Two incomes definitely better than one, Lisa, as long as you’re DINKs. But child-care adds a huge cost, which makes it time to re-evaluate. IMO.
Single parents get the shortest end of the stake here. At least plonkee doesn’t have to pay for babysitting and such.
@Mrs. Micah:
Too true, single parenting is probably the most expensive. I think there are lots of things that you should/would re-evaluate if you have kids, of course re-evaluating doesn’t necessarily mean that you should switch to one income it entirely depends on what you both get out of work (both monetarily and in intangibles).
Very nice article, thought I’d write a follow-up to it.
I don’t even remember what it was like to be single anymore. Been too long, and I wasn’t single that long to begin with. Now MARRIED, I’ve got down cold!
Parenting as a whole is very expensive. Some cost are obvious, like groceries, others happen like Ninja Bills, clothes, scholl etc..
Single Parents have it very rough.
Don’t forget the whole going on holiday issue where we have to pay a twice as much as eveything is set up as twin share!
Interesting post.
I’ve done the single thing and now I’m doing the married thing and I can tell you from a financial point of view, singles have it tough.
Whether you have a house/apartment, car etc couples can share so much more.
Mike
I’m in the middle of buying a condo and I hadn’t actually thought about how unusual it is for a single person to buy real-estate - until everything I signed had lines for two buyers!
Right on!
The amount of extra WORK a single person has to do to maintain life is what strikes me. When you have to do everything from tending the yard to repairing the toilet to schlepping the dog to the vet to buying groceries to fixing food, your life is chuckablock full of chores, with little or no time left for loafing or going out.
And what seems like a pretty good salary is less so when you’re not sharing some of the overhead with another person.
I suspect a friend who earns about what I do thinks I’m pretty chintzy because I won’t hire her housekeeper for $80 a hit (yipe!) and because I don’t entertain a lot. She has a partner who splits those costs with her — alone, I flat can’t afford them.
On the other hand…heh heh!…it’s pretty nice to be free to do what you want to do (or don’t want to do) when you please.
Hi Plonkee - I’ve been away from your blog for a little while with work. Glad to see you’re still plugging away at it!
We are a single income household with 2 young children, and it is pretty tough. For us it makes sense because 1)my wife is able to work on house improvements (she’s a faux painter and interior designer), so in a sense she is earning equity for us even though its not cash in pocket, and 2) the cost of child care is prohibitive.
As a result, I have a day job (working at home) and I supplement that income with programming and writing gigs where I can get them to fit my schedule. But my wife’s contribution has been extremely lucrative - the improvements on the last house turned into significant gains for us when we sold.
My ex-boyfriend once commented on how his oldest brother was able to amass significant savings because he wasn’t married. It seems the brother viewed a wife as an expense. After some discussion, I was able to convince my ex that having a spouse could be of financial benefit, much like having a roommate. Obviously, having kids and potentially having a spouse stay home with them changes things, as would a large income disparity since, if, say, you made $200,000 and a year and your spouse made $20,000 you’d probably choose a lifestyle a bit more lavish than strictly equal contributions would allow.
there seems to be a growing trend for flat sharing now (in London anyway). I’ve noticed it more and more among my peers (I’m 37) and I’ve just started flat sharing myself - last time I did this was when I was in University.
And its actually working out really well.
Like Angell, I am totally cheating by having a housemate. I am 45 and have only lived alone once for about six months (until my sister moved in) plus a couple of months between roommates (while I have a recovery/self rediscovery period).
With a roommate, not only do I pay only half the rent and just over half the utilities (the utilities would be lower in the summer if it were just me, lower in winter if it were just him), I also have someone to talk to without having to go out. I also have access to lots of fine reading materials, DVDs, and guitar music. Also, I have never bought a couch.
@Debbie M:
I wish I’d never had to buy a couch. I lived with what I can only describe as a succession of the worlds worst sofas for the last 10 years. The current one isn’t getting replaced yet because I have other priorities, and it’s perfectly serviceable, but I do not like it one little bit.
Thanks for posting this. I am always a bit envious when two-income households wake up, smell the debt, buckle down, and pay it off fairly quickly. I’ve been pretty good about debt, and am fairly conscientious about my spending. I definitely have room for improvement, but not as much spare money as I might if I had a financial partner!
@bethh:
It is definitely easier for 2 people together to pay down debt, I guess the difficulty comes in ensuring that both parties want to do so.
Interesting post. I think your right on target when you’re thinking about a two income two person family. When a family goes from two to three things change though.
Many things (food, entertainment, vacation, clothing, etc) become more expensive when you add more than two.
Also, as a single adult you have the option of a room/flat mate.
Actually, there is currently no marriage penalty in the US tax code. That was fixed.
I’m single, single income, live on my own, no kids. Good salary. Life is good.
Agree with you about chores/errands. My solution: lower my standards for housekeeping (because I’m never there anyway). Run errands during my lunch hour or on the way home from work. Automate as much as possible.
Oh yeah, my housekeeping standards are pretty low. There just aren’t enough hours in the day to get everything done. As long as it’s not a health hazard, who cares?
im 19 and im looking at moving out on my own i only earn 200 pounds a week after tax and i need to drive to manchester from burnley erery day to work (about 50 miles there and back a day), i dont have much furniture and running a car and travelling expences mean i dont have any money to do anything else, i tried looking for benefits but im really struggling to find any as im quite new to this and not really sre what im looking for, if anyone has any help or advice it would be much appreciated, my email adress is jackson-11@hotmail.co.uk
My husband is (and always has been) very much of the school of thought that two incomes are better than one. As I, myself, happen to enjoy having a career, I have never disagreed with him on this point. In the current economy, however, I am leaning more and more toward trying to convince him to buckle down and have one of us remain at home with the children to alleviate childcare costs, convenience food costs, and expensive commuting costs. I’m glad I’m not a singlton anymore. Many judos to you for managing it on your own without the option available to have it any other way.
Personally, I don’t think staying single is the only option. You can actually save enough money for your future family in order to avoid tax problems.
Really great post and the step by step approach! Thank you for creating the tutorial.
Supra Vulk, Supra Vulk
Supra Shoes Cruizer, Supra Shoes
Cruizer
Supra Shoes Cuban, Supra Shoes
Cuban
We took the decision to live on one income when our eldest child was born ten years ago. It’s been, and still is, a struggle sometimes as the cost of living sky rockets, but the benefit of knowing that the kids have our attention and are not being cared for by strangers makes up for it for us.
Nice post,not like some boring once,i definitely loved every little bit of it! Thanks for posting..
thanks for posting such a nice info. i will bookmark this post.
Nevertheless a lot of people can’t pronounce his or her identify (Lu-bu-TAHn), his or her bank purple only can be quickly recognizable. Christian Louboutin Pumps When i absolutely feel Boots and shoes are, for deficiency of a greater word
I really don’t think that it’s a good idea to live on your own. It’s much better when you have somebody to maintain you.
Other items you may interested in, like Christian Louboutin black pumps,Christian Louboutin Ankle boots, Christian Louboutin wedges uk are also hot sell in our store, welcome to have a look, 100% quality guarantee and free shipping to your door in one weeks. Now it is the time to have your sexy and charming louboutin items from our shop. Many surprise for you.
Well this kind of information is really worth searching for, good information for readers and a value for you as will definitely show the quality of the writer. It’s good to have these kinds of articles around to keep the information flow steady. Helping those who really can make things right in the future, good work!
Thanks
i really like this post thanks for shairng my comment
I just luckily stumbled upon this blog and have been reading along all the blogs posted here. They are really very well written, precise and to the point. Thanks for sharing.
This is a brilliant writing and very pleased to find this site. I couldn’t discover to much different information on your blog. I will surely be back again to look at some other important posts that you have in future.
Thanks for you instructions.
I have been a regular visitor of this site and I love reading blogs posted here. They are truly very well written, precise and to the point. Thanks.
I have not seen such a fabulous post in a while. I am extremely happy that I found this quality stuff and enjoyed reading it. Thanks.
Thanks for the tips, I am going to apply these tips and I’m glad I found this blog because I had no idea about this before
Thanks for the information in this blog.Once again you have proved your efficiency and excellency in your blog work.Keep it up. Since I am the frequent visitor for this blog Waiting for some more new posts from you.You made some very useful and interesting points within your post. I like the way of your explanation. Very useful for all readers.
What is a bit team building activities and how does it work free nursing journals online and where do I get them entry level Mechanical Engineering Internships
I visit this site regularly and I love reading blogs posted here. I have this site already bookmarked in my browser. Thanks for this post.
Thank you for your useful information.I like this kind of post which
Tell us much wander full massage.
Very useful articles. I and my friend to do some research. I am very glad to see such information, I find the very long period of time, was finally I found, thank you.
This is like an advice of a friend. Thank you for this post.
This was very informative. I have been reading your blog a lot over the past few days and it has earned a place in my bookmarks. It is wonderful.I learn a lot from it.thanks for sharing the article.
Its like you read my mind! You appear to know so much about this, like you wrote the book in it or something. I think that you could do with some pics to drive the message home a little bit, but other than that, this is great blog. A great read. I will certainly be back. shears
very nice and awesome blog form you dear i like it and appreciate you on this so i would like to thank you for sharing it with us so nicely blog about new technology is great i like all new technologies so i want that keep it up dear for us dealer license
forma de blog muy bonito e impresionante querida me gusta y agradezco que en este modo, quisiera darle las gracias por compartirlo con nosotros tan bien blog acerca de la nueva tecnología es grande me gusta todas las nuevas tecnologías, así que quiero que mantener querido para nosotros
I really admire the author’s contribution to this blog. He has done a fabulous job in putting this article together. Thanks for sharing.
Awesome blog and great article, thanks for sharing
I adore you stories and i hope you’ll be able to maintain them coming. Honestly it’s difficult to discover an interesting blog these days.
This is called quality blog. I got many informative information from his site. Thanks for share your information with all.
Awesome blog and great article, thanks for sharing
This is an excellent post. I got many unknown information from this site.
It got good posts as well. I will bookmark this site for future viewing. Thanks for sharing.
The topic is remarkable. I actually never think I could have an excellent read by this time until I find out this website. I am thankful for the information. Thank you for being so kind enough to have shared your information with us.
This is an excellent post. I got many unknown information from this informative blog.
I am very glad to read your well written article. Thanks for your wonderful blog.
As soon as I opened the box, the smell of the leather made the difference. Highly recommended. Look as real 17 again movie as pictured.
At first Thank you very much for your nice and awesome blog. Specially I like the way of your explanation. It’s excellent.
I like your blog achievement.Your blog is playing an Important role In internet marketing field.Good.
I’m still learning from you, but I try to reach my goals. Since then enjoy reading all the information that appears on your blog.Keep come. Loved it!
am also interested in this topic. I have spent a lot of time on searching this kind of topic. It is very informative.
Thanks for the informative writing. Would mind updating some good tips about it. I still wait your next place.
If you need more traffic to your website check out the website in my name. It really helped me and i think it can help your website.
The positive comments and do well wishes are very motivational and greatly appreciated.